Wednesday, November 27, 2013

The Most Rapidly Depreciating Currency in the World

By Simon Black

Do you remember the days when travel used to be glamorous and sexy? The mere prospect of getting on an airplane was tremendously exciting. Friends and family would come with you to the gate to see you off and pick you up. 

Today, millions of passengers in the Land of the Free will take off their shoes and assume the "I surrender" pose inside a radiation machine that provides negligible benefit and maximal cost to taxpayers. 

Our modern security theater is a stark contrast to the past. But there's been something else happening over the last several decades that is even more insidious... and far less obvious. 

In 1979, Texas International Airlines (the precursor to Continental) introduced the first modern frequent flier program. American Airlines soon followed, launching their AAdvantage frequent flier program in 1981. 

When the program launched, you could upgrade to a first class seat on the Concorde for 20,000 miles (something that you couldn't even do today). Today, an upgrade to first class between the US and Europe would set you back 50,000 miles, plus $900 in fees. 

In fact, just about every mileage award category has been getting more 'expensive', particularly among the major US carriers. The majority of the increases have taken place in the last several years. 

United Airlines, for example, is raising the number of miles required for most of its awards starting February 1st. The steepest is an 87% increase for first class award seats on United's partner airlines flights to the Middle East. 

A United economy class ticket to Hawaii will increase by 'only' 12%. And business class to Europe and Japan will increase 20%. 

Just like central bankers with paper currencies, airlines are devaluing their miles. 

They have created trillions of miles in the system, many of these through special gimmick promotional giveaways. We've probably all seen the 'sign up for the new credit card and receive 25,000 bonus miles'. 

But just like the real economy, rapidly increasing the money supply (airline miles) devalues the currency and creates inflation. 

That's exactly what's happening here. Airline miles are worth less and less. 

Moreover, the airlines have begun to restrict award seat capacity. If you have ever tried to actually USE your miles, you've probably become very frustrated. Sometimes you have to book those flights a year in advance just to get one crummy seat. 

They've also begun increasing fees on top of the mileage awards-- so now if you want to use miles to upgrade, you have to pay a steep fee on top of the miles. 

Airline miles are a great analogy of how inflation works in the real economy. It's clear that the supply of miles is increasing rapidly. But the effects go unnoticed for a long time. 

Then suddenly, one day, prices go up dramatically (as in the case of United). 

And most people who have been responsibly saving for a rainy day (or that dream trip to Paris) suddenly find that years of their savings are worth less. 

Airline miles are the most rapidly depreciating currency in the world. And they're an interesting sign of things to come with fiat currencies.

Simon Black is Senior Editor  at Follow Sovereign Man on Facebook, Twitter, Google+


  1. Why the fixation with inflation? Every day there is another one of these "hyperinflation due any day" articles.

    CPI All Items:
    Oct 2013: 233.546
    Oct 2008: 216.573

    annual rate of inflation over 5 years: 1.5%/year

    Ron Paul: Collapse of the Dollar
    Uploaded on May 27, 2008

    5 years of fear mongering.

  2. Brilliant analysis. I barely pay attention to my monthly USAir statement anymore, for precisely the reasons mentioned.

    Another thing about the programs that never ceases to amaze me is the way gullible flyers continue to buy extra rapidly depreciating miles each time they book a flight.

    Painful though it is for those of us who are long-term frequent flyers, anyone who lived through the last round of inflation in the US, or who's had the misfortune to be paid in VEFs or ARSs the past five years, understands all too well why inflation is such a fearsome force.

  3. What happened to the whole "private companies have an incentive not to devalue their currencies"? I could be wrong, but it seems to me to show that private currencies would be inflated, just as private airline miles are.

    1. Private companies face the same flawed human condition as public monopolies. The difference is with a private company, its customers are the only ones affected by poor decisions, and other options exist for its customers to choose. Freedom does not produce perfection. It minimizes all the warts created by monopoly.

  4. "The Most Rapidly Depreciating Currency in the World"

    Function: noun
    1 : firm to a code of especially moral or artistic values : incorruptibility 2 : an unimpaired condition : soundness 3 : the quality or state of being complete or undivided

    [end of lesson]