Saturday, December 12, 2015

The Jewish Riot That Broke Out When Kosher Beef Prices Climbed by 6 Cents

From The Economist:
The rise and fall of the Jewish deli

Pastrami on Rye: An Overstuffed History of the Jewish Deli. By Ted Merwin. NYU Press; 245 pages; $26.95.

JEWISH delicatessens may now be known for knishes, latkes and pastrami sandwiches, but back in their heyday, during the 1920s and 1930s in the theatre district in New York, they also served beluga caviar, pâté de foie gras and Chateaubriand steak. Jewish classics were gussied up and defiled: chopped chicken liver was served with truffles. Treyf, like oysters and pork chops, was eaten with abandon alongside kosher delicacies.

In his new book “Pastrami on Rye”, one of the first scholarly histories of the Jewish delicatessen, Ted Merwin, a professor of religion and Judaic studies, tracks the rise and fall of delis. The fruit of more than ten years of research and writing, Mr Merwin’s account shows that delis have been a rich part of the story of Jewish assimilation in America.

The first delicatessens sold mostly German food. For early Jewish immigrants, deli meats were an indispensable reminder of home. When kosher beef prices in America jumped from 12 to 18 cents a pound in 1902, riots broke out in Jewish enclaves throughout the north-east. Jewish women boycotted and picketed slaughterhouses, attacked deli customers and set fire to meat they had first doused in petrol. After Orthodox religious leaders endorsed the movement, the price of beef finally began to drop.

Delis were popularised as restaurants by a new generation of American-born Jews. The peak year for European immigration was 1907, with more than 1m newcomers arriving at Ellis Island, the major hub near New York. Over the next three decades the children of these immigrants sought ways of gaining access to the commercial and social life of the city. Jews found an opening at the deli, a place where they could express loyalty to their heritage in a public setting, and where non-Jews could also sample Jewish culture.

To many, deli food came to symbolise Judaism in a secular form. After his Broadway shows Al Jolson, a famous Jewish singer, would invite the whole audience, Jew and gentile alike, to join him at Lindy’s delicatessen. Martin Kalmanoff, a Jewish songwriter, wrote that at the Stage Deli, “You’ll find debutantes with poodles eatin’ hot goulash and noodles.” In 1926 George Jean Nathan, a theatre critic, declared a “sandwich wave”; Jerome Charyn, a New York writer and historian, has referred to the 1920s as the “delicatessen decade”. Jewish culture was suddenly popular culture. 
Read the rest here.
BTW: The absolutely best pastrami and rye sandwich in San Francisco can be had at the  Wise Sons Jewish Delicatessen, which is attached to the Contemporary Jewish Museum at  736 Mission 3rd & 4th Streets.



  1. Back when I was a kid in Long Island, New York (50's), everything was closed on Sundays EXCEPT Greenberg's deli. So you could buy your Daily News, Journal-American, Herald Tribune, Daily Mirror (NOT the NY Times). And maybe a knish or two.
    Handy, those staggered sabbaths!

  2. If ever in Pittsburgh, try Primanti Bros. pastrami & cheese.